When Can Your Gym Afford to Hire?

Gym coaches with text "Is it time to hire staff?"

Staffing is one of the biggest problems we hear about from gym owners, and it’s a scary one.

When you hire, you take on real financial risk. You’re committing to paying someone regularly, and you have no guarantee the investment will pay off. Most gym owners don’t know when they can actually afford help, so they either avoid hiring for years or hire too early and end up working for their staff.

Below, I’ll show you how to figure out how much you can spend on staff, how much you can pay your next hire and how to tell whether that hire is working.


Why Hiring Matters

Our industry loses a lot of good gym owners to burnout. It’s the common enemy we’re all fighting, and it comes from four places:

  1. Too much work.
  2. Little or no control over your schedule. (If you’ve ever coached split shifts for months on end, you know exactly what I mean.)
  3. A chaotic environment.
  4. Not enough reward for all the effort it takes to deal with numbers 1 to 3.


All four come back to hiring.

To grow your gym, you need a clear head, and you can’t think clearly when you’re burned out. Hiring is the way out of that spiral.

A hire is an investment, the same as new equipment or an expansion of your space. You spend money now because you expect to get it back with interest. To do that well, you need a system to measure the return.


Step 1: Find the Fair Market Value of Your Own Work

Before you look at anyone else, look at the return your gym is getting on you.

You’re probably doing some coaching, sales, marketing and admin. That work has a price, even if you never officially pay yourself for it. Here’s how to calculate it:

  1. List every role and task you perform: coaching, cleaning, marketing, sales, admin and so on.
  2. Write down the hours you spend on each role every week.
  3. Write down the replacement cost for each job. A decent coach will probably cost you $30 to $40 a session. Admin help will cost about $20 to $30 an hour.


Add it all up. That’s the true fair market value of the work you’re putting into your gym.

Example: Say you coach 20 sessions a week at a replacement cost of $30 per session and do 20 hours of admin at $20 an hour. That’s about $1,000 a week, or roughly $4,000 a month.

Now look at your profit-and-loss statement. If it shows $3,000 in profit but doesn’t account for your work, your gym is actually losing about $1,000 a month. If you ever went to sell, a buyer would have to pay someone to do your job, and they’re going to do this exact math.

Your real profit is what’s left after you subtract all expenses and the fair market value of your labor.

If this exercise shows you aren’t truly profitable, your first job is to get profitable. You aren’t ready to hire yet. Adding a paycheck to a gym that’s losing money only digs the hole deeper.

A few options in that situation:

  • Barter for help, such as trading a membership for cleaning.
  • Pare back your model. If you have 30 or 40 members and run eight group classes a day, the schedule isn’t sustainable. Simplifying might be the fastest route to profit.


Step 2: Set Your Salary Cap

Assume you have real profit left after paying yourself fair market value and covering every expense. Your first target is 15% profit. (If you’re having trouble getting there, that’s exactly what we help gym owners do at Two-Brain.)

Once you’re there, you’re close to ready. The next question: How much can you afford to spend on staff?

That number is your salary cap. Here’s how to calculate it:

  • Revenue: Use an average of the last three months. For this example, $20,000 a month.
  • Owner pay (fair market value): From Step 1, $4,000.
  • Operating expenses: Everything except staffing. Let’s say $8,000.
  • Profit target: 15% of $20,000, which is $3,000.


Now subtract:

$20,000 − $4,000 − $8,000 − $3,000 = $5,000

That’s your salary cap: the total pool of money the gym can spend on staff each month.

Fifteen percent profit is a great starting target early in your staffing journey. More advanced gyms with a management layer often target 20%, 25% or even 30%. Don’t get stuck on the number. Start at 15%.

Think like the owner of a sports team. You have $5,000, and your job is to put the best possible roster on the field with that money.

Darren Thornton, a Two-Brain alumnus, used this approach to build a team of seven full-time coaches on salary, with starting pay around $60,000 a year plus benefits. As his revenue grew, his salary cap grew, and every jump in the cap let him offer a real career instead of scattered part-time shifts.


Step 3: Raise the Cap to Invest in Growth

What if $5,000 isn’t enough to make the hire you need to grow?

The way to raise your salary cap is to temporarily lower your profit target.

This works exactly like buying equipment or building out a new section of your space: You spend the money first, and the return comes later.

Let’s drop the profit target in our example from 15% to 10%:

  • Profit falls from $3,000 a month to $2,000.
  • The salary cap rises from $5,000 a month to $6,000.


You’re accepting $1,000 less profit each month to invest $1,000 more in staff. Now the goal is to get paid back as quickly as possible.

The payback looks different depending on the role:

  • Revenue-generating hires are easy to measure. If you hire a coach to run personal training, you can see exactly what that coach brings in.
  • Time-buying hires are trickier. When you hire an admin at $20 to $30 an hour, you’re buying back your own time. The return only shows up if you reinvest that time in higher-level work that grows the business, such as sales, marketing and building relationships with clients.


Matt Michaud, now a Two-Brain mentor, followed this path. He went from wearing every hat at a gym doing $10,000 to $12,000 a month to running a business that does more than $80,000 a month with six full-time staff members. He doesn’t coach classes anymore. Each hire freed up time he reinvested in growth, and that growth funded the next hire.


Step 4: Run a 90-Day Trial

Give yourself a set window to confirm the hire is working. I recommend a 90-day trial.

In our example, you lowered profit to 10% to pay for the hire. The test is simple: Within 90 days, has revenue grown enough to bring profit back to 15%?

If yes, congratulations. The hire worked. Repeat the cycle: Lower your profit target, raise your salary cap, make the next hire, and measure again.

If no, you have a problem. One of two things is happening:

  1. The role isn’t generating revenue the way you expected.
  2. The time freed up by the hire isn’t being reinvested well.


At that point, you either cut the role or fix how you use your time.

As your gym matures and you repeat this cycle, you’ll eventually add a management layer and raise your profit target to 20%, 25% or 30%.


Hire With Confidence

Most gym owners do everything they can to avoid hiring because they think it’s too expensive. Others hire too early and end up taking nothing home while their staff gets paid.

When you hire with a plan, use a salary cap and measure the return on every dollar you put into payroll, you can hire with confidence.

If you want a mentor to walk you through the numbers and help you build a staffing plan for your gym, book a call with our team.

Like
Tweet

One more thing!

Did you know gym owners can earn $100,000+ per year working no more than 20 hours each week? Type your info here and we’ll send it to you.
100k in four hours a day book cover