“I Just Need More Leads”: What the Data Says Instead

Kilo CEO Kaleda Connell with gym background and text "MORE LEADS WON'T FIX IT"

“I just need more leads.”

We hear it on almost every sales call at Two-Brain. I’m sure Kaleda Connell, CEO of Kilo, hears it a lot, too.

Kilo is one of our data partners for the seventh edition of the Two-Brain Business State of the Industry report. Using Kilo’s data, we looked at every step a gym prospect takes, from the first time they show interest to the day they cancel.

Four numbers kept coming up. Here’s what each one means, what the average gym looks like and what standout gyms are doing.


1. Leads

A lead is a person who raises their hand: They fill out a form on your website, message you on Instagram, respond to an ad or call the front desk. You have their contact information, and they’ve said, “I might be interested.”

A lead isn’t a client yet. It’s a chance to start a conversation.

According to Kilo’s data, the average gym gets about 32 leads a month. The range is huge, from rural gyms that don’t run ads to busy gyms in major cities.

Joe at Unleash’d Strength is at the top of that range. Kilo’s numbers show he averages about 250 leads a month, which is more than 3,000 in the last 12 months.

Joe runs ads and events, but his foundation is social media. Kaleda describes his content as quirky and authentic. He doesn’t have a giant following, but his posts connect with the people he wants to reach. He’s put in enough reps on camera to know what works, and he builds his ads the same way.

Joe recently told the Two-Brain group he’s getting $4 leads in the suburbs of D.C. Kaleda and I both remember $4 leads from around 2017. They’re rare now. Since Meta’s Andromeda update in 2025, the platform has favored accounts that also post a lot of organic content.


2. Set Rate

Set rate is the percentage of leads who book an appointment, usually a free consultation or intro session.

If 100 people fill out your form and 25 book a time to come in, your set rate is 25%.

Kilo’s data shows that’s about average: roughly one in four leads books. That means three out of four people who raise their hand never get to a conversation.

Nora Matthews at Her Strength has a 62% set rate. She doesn’t run many ads and doesn’t have a big following. In Kaleda’s view, Nora probably books and sells more people than some gyms that get far more leads.

The difference is focus. Nora’s ideal client is a woman in her 50s who wants to get stronger. Kaleda told the story of a woman who called Nora and said, “My friends love your gym, but nobody on your website looks like me. Do you actually help older women?”

Nora’s website was full of younger people. She rebuilt it so the images showed her actual clients, and she moved to a more visible location. According to Kaleda, her bookings went up right away.

Today, if you scroll through Nora’s site and feed, you see women her clients’ age and a female coach talking about the problems they face. When a 55-year-old woman in her area compares gyms, Nora is the obvious choice.


Why Cost Per Lead Doesn’t Tell the Whole Story

Most gym owners who run ads track one number: cost per lead, or how much they pay for each person who fills out a form. A $10 lead looks better than a $60 lead.

At Two-Brain, we think cost per lead is the wrong scoreboard. Set rate shows why.

Lisa and Dai at Gas Station Fitness in the U.K. run two kinds of ads at the same time. One sends people to a lead form inside Facebook. The other sends people to a landing page on their own website. When we analyzed their numbers, here’s what we found:

  • Facebook lead-form leads were six times cheaper.
  • Only 5% of lead-form leads booked an appointment.
  • 40% of landing-page leads booked.


Based on cost per lead, the lead form wins easily. But a lead that costs six times as much and books eight times as often works out to about 25% cheaper per booked appointment.


3. Show Rate

Show rate is the percentage of booked appointments where the person actually shows up.

If 10 people book and eight arrive, your show rate is 80%.

Kaleda explained why this number is the hardest to measure across the data set. Software can track when a lead books, cancels or reschedules, but the owner has to mark each appointment as “showed” or “no-show.” In about half of cases, that never happens.

At Two-Brain, we consider a show rate above 70% good. The best gyms in Two-Brain are above 80%.

Stan Skolfield at Skolfield Sports Performance, a gym that mostly trains young athletes, does something Kaleda sees as a big help with show rate.

When a lead comes in, Stan calls and explains the price and what to expect before the assessment is booked. His program costs $1,500 to start. In Kaleda’s view, parents who book after that call are more likely to show up because they already know the cost and aren’t coming in wondering whether they can afford it.

When a parent says the program is expensive, Stan has an answer: “It’s only expensive if he doesn’t get results.”


4. Close Rate

Close rate is the percentage of appointments that end in a sale.

If 10 people come in for a consultation and five sign up, your close rate is 50%.

According to our 2026 State of the Industry report, the average close rate is 60.9%.

Before Kilo, Kaleda owned a gym in a town of 2,300 people. The close rate she aimed for there, and the one she still uses as a benchmark, is about 70%. She points out that a 100% close rate isn’t the goal. When everyone says yes, the price may be too low.

In Kaleda’s experience, the best closers listen, add value, listen again and lay out a clear plan to get the client from where they are to where they want to be. Then they ask for the sale.


What a Typical Month Looks Like

“I just need more leads” sounds like the answer, but leads are only the first step. Between “I’m interested” and “I’m in,” potential clients drop out at every stage: when they’re asked to book, when it’s time to show up and when it’s time to buy.

That’s why we say leads are the wrong scoreboard. The full funnel tells the real story.

The seventh edition of the Two-Brain Business State of the Industry report has the full set of benchmarks, plus much more data on marketing, sales and retention. Get your copy here.

Like
Tweet

One more thing!

Did you know gym owners can earn $100,000+ per year working no more than 20 hours each week? Type your info here and we’ll send it to you.
100k in four hours a day book cover